Mbeki Claims No Progress Since 2018; Author Cites Infrastructure and Economic Gains
Former South African President Thabo Mbeki recently asserted that no positive developments have occurred in the country since Cyril Ramaphosa took office in 2018. In response, a senior research fellow has detailed significant achievements in infrastructure, economic stability, and energy security during this period to challenge the former leader's characterization of the tenure.
Former South African President Thabo Mbeki has stated that nothing positive has happened in the country since Cyril Ramaphosa assumed office in 2018. The comment, made regarding the current president’s tenure at the Union Buildings, suggests that if Ramaphosa were to infer from recent political pressures—specifically the African National Congress’s performance in local government elections—that he should resign, Mbeki would be inclined to agree.
The assertion has drawn sharp criticism for overlooking documented developments in infrastructure, economic policy, and public service delivery. Critics argue that labeling the entire period as devoid of progress ignores substantial government initiatives and measurable outcomes achieved over the past several years.
One prominent counter-argument highlights that the government committed more than R1-trillion to public infrastructure over a three-year period. This figure represents the largest amount budgeted from the fiscus for such purposes, aimed at renewing roads, ports, rail, energy, and water systems. The scale of this commitment was reflected in the market response: government’s first infrastructure bond was more than twice oversubscribed.
To facilitate further development, the administration established the Infrastructure Fund as a blended finance facility and created Infrastructure SA to coordinate massive public building projects. Regulatory amendments were also introduced to ease private sector investment in infrastructure. In 2024 alone, new public and private sector projects announced were valued at R445-billion, marking the largest fixed investment in infrastructure since 2021.
Economic diversification efforts have also yielded specific results. The government finalized master plans for eight industries: clothing, poultry, sugar, automotive, furniture, steel, tourism, and forestry. These plans resulted in total investment commitments of R82.5-billion and the creation of 6,500 jobs.
Support for small and medium enterprises (SMEs) has expanded significantly. The government provided more than R2.5-billion in support to over 180,000 SMEs, alongside R1-billion in guarantees. This builds upon the government-guaranteed bounce-back loan scheme introduced in 2022. Additionally, approximately R15-billion has been invested in black-owned businesses through the Black Industrialist programme.
Transportation infrastructure has seen tangible improvements. Passenger rail services have been restored on 35 out of 40 priority commuter rail corridors. The state-owned passenger rail operator, Prasa, recorded more than 100-million passenger trips in the 2025/26 financial year. Furthermore, around 330 of 600 new, locally manufactured trains have been delivered.
The tourism sector has also reached record highs. South Africa grew international tourist arrivals to a record 10.5-million last year, a feat supported by visa reforms and targeted tourism promotion campaigns.
On the macroeconomic front, significant milestones have been achieved. The government secured the country’s removal from the Financial Action Task Force (FATF) grey list in October of the previous year. This followed the completion of all 22 action items in the plan adopted when South Africa was greylisted in February 2023.
Credit ratings have also improved. In November of the previous year, S&P Global awarded South Africa its first sovereign credit rating upgrade in nearly two decades. Moody’s subsequently raised the country’s rating outlook from stable to positive in May of this year.
Economic indicators show continued stabilization. Early this year, the economy recorded four consecutive quarters of growth. The government achieved two consecutive primary budget surpluses, and inflation fell to its lowest level in 20 years, enabling lower interest rates.
Energy security has improved dramatically due to the National Energy Crisis Committee. The country moved from experiencing 330 days of load shedding in 2023 to more than 500 consecutive days without load shedding by the end of September this year. Eskom’s Energy Availability Factor reached 75% in July, and the utility reported a profit of R30.3-billion for the 2025/26 financial year.
Institutional integrity has also been addressed through leadership changes. New appointments at the Hawks have restored credibility and stability to the unit. These changes led to actions against corruption and the establishment of the National Prosecuting Authority’s Investigating Directorate Against Corruption, tasked with prosecuting those involved in state capture and other significant corruption cases.
Critics of Mbeki’s statement suggest that his view may be influenced by historical political rivalries, particularly the competition for leadership between Mbeki and Ramaphosa in 1996. However, analysts emphasize that reducing complex national challenges to the failures of one individual is intellectually lazy and politically unfair.
The debate underscores broader discussions about accountability and legacy in South African politics. As former President Nelson Mandela once advised regarding his own retirement commentary on government matters, there are precedents for reflecting on the appropriateness of such pronouncements from outside the current administration.
U.Neumann--BlnAP